6 Tips for Disagreeing Constructively

(If you’d rather consume this article in audio form, here you go.)

Disagreement can be frustrating, of course, but there is also great value in it. When we disagree with someone—whether in a relationship or a political discussion—instead of digging in your heels and defending your position at all costs, you can use it as an opportunity to gain a better understanding of your interlocutor’s point of view. The reward is a broader and more robust worldview.

For the past few years, I’ve noticed a concerning trend: People in the U.S. (possibly worldwide?) are becoming increasingly incapable of disagreeing with one another in a constructive manner.

Social media algorithms are exacerbating the problem. They trap us in content bubbles that insulate us from any viewpoints other than those with which we already agree. It’s as if we live in digital gated communities, isolated from other ideological neighborhoods.

This is an insidious problem. Left unresolved, it will have disastrous consequences, not only for our personal relationships, but for democracy at large. Not being exposed to opposing perspectives atrophies our ability to relate to the people who hold those perspectives, leading to a sense of disconnection from our fellow citizens. We fear what we don’t know. Thus, we avoid those with unfamiliar views, even if they’re our next-door neighbor. As a result, our thinking becomes rigid and our worldview becomes increasingly myopic and resistant to being updated with new information.

Darker still are the larger social consequences. In the absence of robust discourse, humans—like other animals—tend to resort to physical violence as a means of getting our point across. It has taken humanity many thousands of years and an unimaginable amount of bloodshed to learn this lesson: the most sustainable way to resolve conflict is through conversation. If we wish to avoid riots, wars, and political upheaval, we must learn to disagree constructively. This can be broken down into two parts:

  1. Actively exposing ourselves to perspectives different from our own with the intent to understand

  2. Engaging with those perspectives in good faith

Just as a strenuous workout session increases our strength and endurance, engaging with opposing viewpoints can make us intellectually sharper, insightful, and more resilient.

I recently spoke with someone who I believe is addressing the first part of this solution very well. Her name is Harleen Kaur and she is a former NASA engineer and the founder of Ground News.

Ground News is a news platform whose goal is to combat media bias by allowing users to compare how different news outlets from across the political spectrum are covering the same story.

You can listen to my conversation with Harleen here.

But how do we address the second part? How do we constructively engage with people whose views conflict with our own?

I’ve distilled some of the most effective principles I’ve found for disagreeing constructively, drawing on research from communications, psychology, and my own experience.

These principles are not meant to be implemented rigidly. Adapt them to suit your personality and the context of the situation.

6 Tips for Disagreeing Constructively

1. Seek first to understand, then to be understood.

The most basic prerequisite for resolving any disagreement is to understand what the disagreement is actually about and what the other person believes. This is trickier than it sounds.

In order to do this, you must resist the desire to persuade people of your own point of view, at least at first. This desire will be strong, naturally. But you must not give in. Instead, you must seek first to understand, then to be understood. 

Demonstrate to the person you’re arguing with that you truly understand their side. Instead of immediately dismissing their views and stating your own, listen to their argument and then rephrase it in your own words to prove to them you understand. This is far from easy. But if you do it, you will be handsomely rewarded. Beyond just being the respectful thing to do, there are practical reasons to make the effort to understand other people’s perspectives.

First, when people feel heard, it goes a long way to promote trust and good will and helps smooth out rough patches in the conversation. Conversely, when people do not feel like they’re being heard or understood, they tend to dig their heels in even further.

Secondly, it makes your argument stronger. Cutting yourself off from other perspectives makes you intellectually weak because you don’t know how your interlocutor thinks. Even if your goal is to “defeat” your opponent (which I don’t recommend) you cannot do that until first understanding their position.

Finally, it will improve your relationships. As the old saying goes, “People don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care.” Show people you are acting in good faith and your disagreements will no longer be obstacles to connection but opportunities to strengthen your relationships.

Of course, the paradox of understanding “the other side” is that we begin to see them less as the other side because we understand more about where they’re coming from. They become less like opponents and more like teammates.

2. Restate their position better than they can.

This is how you prove you’re listening. Echo the other person’s perspective in your own words. It’s a good rule of thumb to only state your views after you can restate the other person’s views to their satisfaction. This might sound something like:

“So, if I understand you correctly, what you're saying is XYZ…Is that right?”
“I want to make sure I’m following you…”
“Just to make sure we’re on the same page, you’re saying…”"

Pro tip: If you can manage it, try making their point even stronger than they did. Not only will it demonstrate that you’re listening with the intent to understand, it also encourages trust and makes your argument appear stronger and more credible, once you reveal it.

3. Be honest about what you don’t know.

Not even the smartest people in the world know everything about everything. Don’t pretend you do. Especially when discussing contentious topics, be honest about what you know and what you don’t know. When you’re honest about what you don’t know, you’ll seem more credible when you assert something you do know. When you humble yourself, you disarm people and give them an opportunity to be gracious toward you.

4. Assume other people’s motives are just as noble as your own.

It’s easy to dismiss those who disagree with us as ignorant or misinformed. It’s much harder to consider that these people may be just like us: decent human beings who are trying to understand reality and navigate it as best they can given the resources they have.

Most people are just as sincere about their point of view as we are about ours. Assume the other person’s reasons for their views are just as valid as your reasons for your views. Then make it your job to understand those reasons. Be genuinely curious about how they think.

Of course, some people do not operate in good faith. Trolls and bad actors exist, after all. But as long as someone is being reasonably respectful and trying to make their points, give them the benefit of the doubt.

5. Ask questions.

People love to be asked questions. It makes us feel important and respected. It’s also a fantastic alternative to assuming the other person’s position.

“How did you come to that view?”
”What do you think of people who say XYZ?”
”Where did you learn that?”

Whenever you disagree with someone, approach the conversation as if you're just trying to clarify your own thoughts. And in truth, this is what you should be doing. Research has shown that, when tested, we generally tend to know less than we think we do on a given topic. We often conflate strong feelings and intuitions with actual knowledge.

Before countering someone’s position, a useful question is: Are you open to a different perspective on this?

6. Try to see the humanity in everyone.

Humans are tribal creatures by nature. Our default pattern is to otherize those we deem different from us. These differences can be physical, cultural, characterological, and ideological.

To counterbalance this natural tendency, we must remember that people are much more than their beliefs. Our perceived opponents are rarely the one-dimensional monsters our minds have made them out to be. We must remember that the person with whom you’re speaking is human being with hopes, dreams, anxieties, and problems, just like us. Furthermore, shaming people is a terrible strategy for influencing them. It often causes them to adopt even more extreme views.

Finally, when we dismiss a person or a group based solely on certain views we don’t like, we cut ourselves off from the possibility of discovering other views of theirs which may be insightful. Almost everyone has a diamond or two hidden in the rough.

The Takeaway

True progress is made not by isolating ourselves from opposing perspectives but by actively engaging with them. Deep understanding begins when we make a serious attempt to hear where our perceived opponents are coming from.

Of course, there is a catch to all this. The downside of exposing yourself to opposing views is that it’s uncomfortable and emotionally taxing. Unfortunately, the downside of not doing so is that you never learn anything new. Remember the old proverb: “A wise person knows there is something to be learned from everyone.”


If you'd like to support the work I do and also get access to my best content, you can sign up to become a member here.